Originally Posted By soupsoup

Now, with endless fatuous commentary.

ninety9:

Depending on whom you poll, some would say YM has ads — they are in service of fund raising, but as dajiner, they spoil the purity of the reader experience as much as one for True Blood (visually speaking). That there is a morally defensible goal (help school kids!) to the ad doesn’t mean it isn’t using the same logic of “visual distraction from editorial to effect a behavior.” YM isn’t “ad” free — rather, it does not accept payment for promotion, and doesn’t promote (for free or pay) profit-generating enterprises. Again, I’m not trying to parse the superiority of such a stance, but I started by saying I was talking visual presentation.

Well that’s reaching a bit far and if you go down that road even more then NOTHING can be devoid of a “hidden” ad or goal to prevent spoiling the purity of the reader experience. Following your logic, if I just blogged “adaklhfalhfafhsasas” all day long, that could (besides risking a cease and desist from Choire) be seen as an ad in service of WASTING YOUR FUCKING TIME, INC. Actually, I bet people would pay for that.

Notes
  1. ninety9 reblogged this from youngmanhattanite and added:
    Again, I was talking about very particularly the form — since advertising is simply ‘the calling attention to’ is it’s...
  2. youngmanhattanite reblogged this from ninety9 and added:
    go down that road even more then NOTHING can be devoid...“hidden” ad or
  3. ninety9 reblogged this from youngmanhattanite and added:
    Depending on whom you poll, some would say YM has ads — they are in service of fund raising, but as dajiner, they spoil...
  4. youngmanhattanite reblogged this from ninety9 and added:
    Hey, that’s my Meet-Up! Also,...think my personal anti-ad stance
  5. ryanbrown reblogged this from spiers
  6. soupsoup reblogged this from spiers and added:
    find any common ground on...they’ve placed...proof that...
  7. ninety9 reblogged this from spiers and added:
    Answering as a dajiner, I provide the following data points: Some people are turned off by practices they deem...
  8. spiers reblogged this from soupsoup
  9. pareene reblogged this from spiers and added:
    That is a very good point. SPECIAL ADVERTISING SECTION THE PAREENINGTON LAW JOURNAL PRESENTS TUMBLR ATTORNEYS 2009:...
  10. soupsoup reblogged this from spiers and added:
    Spiersblr Yes it is...just as awful. It’s just as annoying
  11. youngmanhattanite reblogged this from spiers and added:
    School is in session, kids.
  12. spiers reblogged this from soupsoup and added:
    That’s true, but...fail to see the contradiction. I’m not sure why the two would be...
  13. andrewgraham reblogged this from soupsoup and added:
    Whatever they are, how can we get Balk or Sheila or someone else to start writing them?
  14. soupsoup posted this

other news is designed by manasto jones, powered by tumblr and best viewed with safari.